I ran one final update today that should have reset the dates stories were created and the dates they were updated, and they should reflect what was found over on the old archive. So if you're looking for something you know was created in 2009, the original date is back on the story.
Also, if anyone would like to volunteer to become an admin, please let me know. There's really nothing much to do, but it's better to have more than one admin than not. You can contact me at email@example.com or on our Facebook page at facebook.com/Squidge.org or just leave a message on here.